Who has the best rum selection?

Turtle Dean

SBH Member
My hubby has become a real rum enthusiast. I was hoping to take him to the Caribbean Rum Awards but it didn’t work out this year. If we came for a visit, what restaurants would have the best selection? Thanks.
 
Capture d’écran 2025-10-19 à 5.23.52 PM.png

Capture d’écran 2025-10-19 à 5.24.10 PM.png

Capture d’écran 2025-10-19 à 5.24.28 PM.png
 
That is very helpful. Thank you. This will make shopping in Gustavia even more irresistible to my husband. He also enjoys a cigar with his rum after dinner. I know Francois Plantation used to have a lovely bar but maybe not so much anymore.
 
That is very helpful. Thank you. This will make shopping in Gustavia even more irresistible to my husband. He also enjoys a cigar with his rum after dinner. I know Francois Plantation used to have a lovely bar but maybe not so much anymore.
It still has a lovely, small bar & a “cigar room” (at least, as of the past season).
 
My hubby has become a real rum enthusiast. I was hoping to take him to the Caribbean Rum Awards but it didn’t work out this year. If we came for a visit, what restaurants would have the best selection? Thanks.
La Case has great selection of Agricole rum. Get him a tasting or class with Victoria it was fun and well worth it. Just plan on a nap that afternoon... They can ship to states also. Cigars, of course the great girls in St Jean at Casa Del Habano. Bring some home also. On another note... I just got back from Key West, great rum distillery there with a great tour and tasting, Papa's Pilar.
 
As a guy that enjoys both a cigar and rum, what is your favorite rum? Tell me how you enjoy it, sipping or in a cocktail? If it is a cocktail, what is the cocktail of preference?

The best rum joints the I have found are in Old San Juan, but they specialize in rum from the island! The Casita on the harbor makes a wonderful rum old fashion….
 
Top